Skip to content
Being rejected with the denial letter is infuriating. It can feel like a betrayal. But this is not the end of struggle for you. You can make successful settlements by knowing the system and using the insurers own system rules against them. This is your guide to exactly doing so.
You were faithfully paying your premiums. You had held up your end of the bargain. Now, when you need them the most, your insurance company has said no. This rejection is not only failure financially, but an injustice par excellence. But there is more power to you than you may imagine.
This should be a comprehensive guide to providing you with the knowledge to fight back. We will guide you through all of the insurance appeal process. You will learn how to make an ironclad case. You will learn how to earn that “no” and you will be able to get the compensation you deserve.
The Anatomy of a Denial: Why Insurers Say No
The first step is knowing your opponent. Insurance companies are NOT your friends. They are profit making businesses. Their goal is to pay out as little money as possible. Your objective is to maximize claim payout. This is what came to be the basic conflict in every claim.
Many denials are automated. A detail is flagged by a computer algorithm. Or an overworked, under-trained adjuster misses out key information. They are not always doing so out of malice. Sometimes, it is the simple, systemic incompetence. This is one of the weaknesses that you can exploit.
They try to find justifications for not giving you. This includes things like policy exclusions, not getting deadlines met or not having all necessary documentation. Knowing these common tactics is the first thing you can do towards a strategy to be a successful settler. Your appeal must be directly opposed to the reason they have given for denying you.
Your First Move: Deconstructing the Denial Letter
Your denial letter is the most important piece of evidence that you have. Do not just skim it. Read it carefully. It is the blueprint to your appeal. The insurance company is required by law to give out the reason behind the denial. This is your starting point.
Identify the specific reason why. Does it mention any particular exclusion under your policy? Does it say that you did not give necessary information? Or is the reason indistinct and confusing? Vague reasons in many cases are a symptom of a weak denial, good news for you.
Once you have the reason get your policy documents. Go find the section to which the reference they are making is referring to. Compare, contrast, and dissect their interpretation on the text in mind. Many times their reasoning is a biased reading of the language of the policy document. This difference is the leverage.
Building an Unshakeable Case: The Power of Evidence
Words are not enough. Your appeal must be backed up by overwhelming proof. Your work is to amass each and every piece of evidence that proves your point. Leave no stone unturned. This is how you demonstrate to them that you are serious.
This evidence can be lots of things. Have new and clearer photos and videos. Get written statements of witnesses. Gather all receipts, invoices and repair estimates. If relevant, a copy of the official police or fire report should be secured. The more you have, the better.
Think and wonder like the detective making up a case. Organize everything out in chronological order. Label each document clearly. Under one bump make a master file with copies of everything. A well organised, well supported with evidence, submission demonstrates to the adjuster that you are prepared for a long fight. It makes successful settlements a lot more likely to occur.
Documentation: The Bedrock of Successful Settlements
Your paper trail is your life-line. Every phone call, email and letter should be recorded. Keep a communication log. Take note of the date, time, and name of the person that you spoke with. Sum up what has been discussed. This log can prove important later as critical evidence.
This careful observation of records does two things. First, it makes it impossible for the insurance company to make “he said, she said” claims. The second thing it shows is that you are diligent and professional. It sends an indication that you are not an easy target and give up.
Avoid the Most Common Filing Errors to avoid delays in your compensation, double-check all your paperwork. Small mistakes can be used by the insurer as an easy excuse for delays or denials. Don’t give them that opening. Be precise and thorough.
Expert Opinions: Your Secret Weapon
Sometimes, your word is inadequate. You need someone credible to support your side. The argument of the insurance company can be demolished by an independent expert. This is a great tool to overturn insurance denial.
Consider hiring a independent contractor or engineer or public adjuster. Their written report can give a professional assessment that is in direct conflict with the findings of the insurer. The price to pay for this report is often a small cost to pay for a much larger settlement. Powerful Video Evidence coupled with an expert report may be unstoppable.
The Formal Appeal: Your Path to Successful Settlements
It is time for the appeal letter to be written. This is a formal document of business. It is not a place to let out your anger. Your tone should be in a firm, professional and factual manner. Let your evidence speak for itself aka Let your evidence do the talking. It is necessary for the letter to be well structured.
You need to start with a clear statement of you purpose. Include your name, policy number and claim number. State on the letter that you are appealing the denial on Date of Letter, State. Make it easy on them to find your file. This is a very important section of any claim reapproval guide.
Then, work out their reason for denial, in a logical way. Use headings to include your argument. For each point that they made, give your counter-argument. Right away follow it with a reference to your supporting evidence. The following examples: “You allege that the damage to the roof was ‘wear and tear.’ However, see Exhibit A, the report from a licensed engineer, John Doe.”
Crafting a Winning Appeal Letter: A Strategic Guide
Your appeal letter should tell a good story. It should lead the new adjuster to only one possible conclusion – your claim is good. Do not make them look for information. Make your case so strong that it is easiest to approve the claim.
Make your sentences brief and to the point. Avoid emotional language. Rather than my heart sank, write-property made it uninhabitable. Stick to the facts. The goal is to end up getting paid, not getting sympathy. This focus is important for those who want to get denied claim help.
You should always close your letter with an actual demand. State the exact value of money that you are seeking for repairs or replacement. Also, set a deadline. “I expect a written response to this appeal within 30 days or so.” This creates a sense of urgency, and lets people know that you mean business. For further detail on how you can do this in more detail, Appeal a Rejected Claim through our step by step instructions.
The Critical Elements of an Appeal for Successful Settlements
Your appeal package must be complete. And it is supposed to have included the appeal letter itself. Behind that, affix copies of all your evidence. This includes the original denial letter. Create a table of contents for your evidence.
Send this package by certified mail and return receipt requested. This provides legal proof that they got it and when. It prevents them from later taking the contention that the appeal was lost. This small step is not negotiable in order to achieve successful settlements.
Do not send your original documents. Always send copies that are high quality. Keeping your originals in a safe place. You are constructing a file of a legal case. So treat it the way you think it deserves.
Escalation: When the Internal Appeal Fails
What if they deny you again? Do not panic. This is very much part of the process. The internal appeal is only the first level. At this point, you have a right to appeal your case to an independent third party. This is where you have a huge surge of success.
Many policyholders surrender after the initial denial. Even more abandon the second one. The insurance company is relying on this. By going ahead you are telling them that you are not like most people. You are a serious contender in the battle to be your claim.
The External Review Process for Overturning Denials
Most states require some kind of external review process (particularly on health insurance claims). This means that your case would reviewed by an independent review organization (IRO). These are not men employed by your insurance company. They have no bias.
The IRO will look at the same evidence that you submitted. They will also check the file of the insurer. Their decision is often legally binding to the insurance company. This is a powerful tool to undo insurance denial because it takes the decision out of the hands of the insurer.
According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the external review process is an important consumer protection process. It ensures that claim decisions are based on terms of medical necessity and policy not the financial interests of an insurer.
Filing a Complaint: Getting Your State on Your Side for Successful Settlements
At the same time, you can make a written complaint. Every state has a Department of Insurance (or agency equivalent). Their job is to regulate the insurers and protect the consumers. A complaint from this department gets the attention of an insurer fast.
Visit your State’s department of Insurance’s website. You can usually make a complain for free, online. Give a brief analysis of your case. Include your policy number including the claim number. Glue your letters of denials and your appeal letter. Find your department of your state at the official site of the NAIC.
The department is going to initiate an inquiry. They will require a formal response from the insurance provider. This is putting pressure on the company. It can often result in a rapid reverse and is an enormous step towards successful settlements.
The Nuclear Option: Understanding Bad Faith and Legal Action
Sometimes, dissent among an insurer is not a simple disagreement. It becomes “bad faith.” This is a legal term. It means that the insurance company refused your claim without having a reasonable basis. Or they engaged in cheating practices for not paying.
Examples for bad faith include:
- Unreasonably postponing your claim.
- Failing to do proper investigation.
- Distorting facts or policies provisions.
- Offering ridiculous low settlement amount.
If you think your money is in bad faith, it is time to discuss it with an attorney. A bad faith lawsuit is not something to be taken lightly. It enables you to sue for the original amount of the claim. You can also file sued for emotional distress and punitive damages. This is the ultimate a way of securing successful settlements.
A legal concept that you must know is rescission. This is when an insurer will attempt to retroactively cancel your policy after you experienced a claim. A lot of times they will claim you made a misstatement on your original application. This is a very aggressive tactic and is usually a sign of bad faith.
Negotiation Tactics to Maximize Your Claim Payout
Even if the insurer does reopen your claim, his or her initial offer may be low. They are testing you. They want to see if you will happy to take a percentage of what you are owed. You will have to be ready to negotiate. This is an important skill in order to maximize claim payout.
Never accept the first offer. In all cases, there must be an offer and a counteroffer. Your counteroffer should be supported by your evidence. Use the estimates/receipts of your contractor. Justify every dollar that you are demanding. This is like a bargain of business. Treat it that way.
Check Out Try to understand the reasons Why Submissions Fail in order to soften your position. With knowledge of common pitfalls, you can argue a case that is very hard to argue against. Your goal is not just for you to get a “yes”, it’s to get the “right yes”.
The Art of the Counteroffer: A Key to Successful Settlements
When you make a counter offer, make it in writing. Restate the best points of your case. Polite way to reject his or her initial offer. Make your new demand well understood. Nor be ready for several rounds of back-and-forth. Patience is a virtue of this process.
If the negotiations stall, remind them what your other alternatives are. Mention the complaint you filed with the state insurance. Hint to your willingness to seek legal action for bad faith. This can often help to break a stalemate. To learn more study on how to Negotiate Higher Settlements effectively.
Legal information resources such as FindLaw offer plenty of articles on the law of insurance and negotiation. Arming yourself with this knowledge helps you to be confident. It can help you stick up for yourself and fight to gain compensation you are due to secure fair and successful settlements.
Conclusion
Being denied any insurance is daunting. The process is intended to make you feel helpless and want you to give up. But you are not powerless. By knowing the system, strictly collecting evidence and crafting a strategic appeal, dramatically change the odds to your advantage. This is the basis for taking rejection and turning it into resolution.
Your fight takes place step by step. It starts with deconstructing their denial and finishes with you with a check in hand. Each and every phase, from the internal appeal to a potential external review, is a battle. But if you are persistent and prepared, you may win these fights. This discipline approach is what creates successful settlements.
Remember that it is absolutely right for you. You paid for a guarantee of protection. Now, you must hold the insurer to his or her word. Do not have control over automated systems or systems that adjust that favor one side over the other control your financial future. Use this claim reapproval guide to fight back and stand firm, and demand what you are owed.
This journey is a tough one, but one that is well worth it. By acting as follows, you are not merely making a claim, you are demanding justice. You are taking charge of the story and creating your own way to successful settlements.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Most policies have a time limit of 180 days from the denial to file an internal appeal but you must check your particular policy documents. State laws can also impact on this timeline so act quickly if you wish to preserve your rights and begin the insurance appeal process.
Yes, you can often take care of the internal appeal and state insurance complaint yourself. However, if you suspect bad faith, or the claim is very large and complex, it is highly recommended you consult with an attorney to establish successful settlements.
The greatest error is writing an emotional, angry letter without adequate proof. A successful appeal is a business argument. There needs to be some professional, factual statement, which does have undeniable proof to help refute the insurer’s stated reason for the insurer denying coverage.
No. It is against the law for an insurance company to take any action against you for making a legitimate complaint to a state Regulator. These consumer protection laws stand to ensure that you can exercise your rights without fear of retribution.
Yes. An offer that doesn’t acknowledge your documentable losses because it’s “lowball” is a constructive denial. Reject it; start negotiations with a counteroffer supported with your evidence is a step you should take: this is a key step to maximize claim payout.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute professional financial or legal advice. Policy terms, coverage, and the claims process are subject to change and vary by state and individual policy. We strongly recommend consulting with a licensed public adjuster, attorney, or insurance professional to discuss your specific situation before making any decisions.
